BLUE JAYS 3, YANKEES 1
Former Yankee Russell Martin hit a two-out infield RBI single in the bottom of the eighth inning off Dellin Betances to break a 1-1 tie as Toronto rallied late to defeat New York on Monday at Rogers Centre in Toronto.
The Yankees entered the inning with a 1-0 lead on the strength of seven shutout innings from right-hander Chase Whitley. But Josh Donaldson and Jose Bautista hit consecutive one-out singles off right-hander Chris Martin.
Betances then replaced Martin and was greeted by a bloop RBI double off the bat of Edwin Encarnacion that tied the game. One out later, Martin hit a ball down the third-base line on which Chase Headley was able to make a diving stop. However, Garrett Jones was unable to dig out Headley’s one-hop throw and both Bautista and Encarnacion scored on the play.
R.A. Dickey (1-3) yielded just one run on three hits and three walks with no strikeouts in eight innings to earn the victory.
Martin (0-1) was charged with the loss in one of the rare occasions this season that the Yankees’ bullpen was unable to protect a lead. They entered play in second place in the American League in bullpen ERA.
Brett Cecil pitched a perfect ninth to earn his second save.
The loss dropped the season record for the Yankees to 16-10 but they remain two games ahead of the second-place Tampa Bay Rays in the American League East. The Blue Jays are 13-14 and 3 1/2 games behind the Yankees.
- Whitley was brilliant and he deserved a much better fate. He shut out the high-powered Blue Jays on six hits, did not walk a batter and fanned six in what was only his second start of the season replacing Masahiro Tanaka in the rotation. Whitley also showed some “Houdini-like” skills by wriggling out of two tough spots. With one out in the third, Ezequiel Carrera laid down a bunt that Whitley fielded and threw wildly down the right-field line for a two-base error that allowed Carrera to advance to third. But Whitley escaped by striking out Devon Travis and retiring Donaldson on a groundout. In the sixth, Travis led off with a single and Donaldson followed with a double. However, Whitley kept the Jays from scoring by getting Bautista on a groundout, striking out Encarnacion and inducing Kevin Pillar to hit a weak infield popup. Whitley’s ERA after two starts is 0.75.
- The Yankees were able to score a run off Dickey in the seventh on a leadoff double by Carlos Beltran. He advanced to third on a groundout by Stephen Drew and he scored on a groundout off the bat of Jones. Beltran was 1-for-3 but he actually hit the ball hard all three times off Dickey’s knuckleball. Beltran entered the game batting .197 and the Yankees need him to get going with the bat.
- Jacoby Ellsbury was 1-for-4 with a single in the sixth, which extended the 31-year-old outfielder’s hitting streak to seven games. Ellsbury is 15-for-30 (.500) in that span.
- I was not happy with manager Joe Girardi’s decision to rest both first baseman Mark Teixeira and catcher Brian McCann in this game. Those two hitters combined the night before against the Boston Red Sox for a double, a home run and four RBIs in an 8-5 victory. I can understand resting McCann because you do need to find a day to rest a catcher. However, Teixeira and McCann are the No. 4 and No. 5 hitters in the lineup so Girardi had a struggling Beltran batting fourth and a struggling Drew hitting fifth in their place. It is lucky the Yankees managed even one run with the lineup they deployed.
- Here is another criticism for Girardi. He thought enough about replacing Beltran in right-field defensively with Chris Young to begin the bottom of the eighth. But he did not think of inserting Teixeira at first in place of Jones. Is it possible that a five-time Gold Glove award winner like Teixeira digs out Headley’s one-hop throw in the eighth? If that had happened the Yankees would have gone into the ninth tied 1-1 instead of losing 3-1.
- One last Girardi criticism. In the ninth, he allowed Alex Rodriguez and Young to hit to start the inning, as he should. However, he opted not to use either McCann or Teixeira to pinch-hit for Drew. Instead he chose to use Gregorio Petit, who was batting .200. It was almost as if Girardi conceded the game after the Blue Jays scored three runs. It was just odd.
The Yankees continue their three-game series with the Blue Jays on Tuesday.
Right-hander Michael Pineda (3-0, 3.73 ERA) will get the start for the Yankees. Pineda held the Rays to two runs on six hits and he fanned five in 5 2/3 innings in a victory on Wednesday.
He will be opposed by right-hander Marco Estrada (1-0, 0.84), who will be making his first start of the season after the Blue Jays optioned rookie left-hander Daniel Norris to Triple-A Buffalo. Estrada will be limited to 75 pitches so watch the Yankees keep attacking the first pitch and make easy outs like fools.
Game-time will be 7:07 p.m. EDT and the game will be broadcast by the YES Network.